When 50-Gallon Electric Makes Sense
The 50-gallon electric water heater is the right choice when your home runs on electricity and your household has more than two or three people. A 40-gallon electric tank can be stretched thin in a 4-person household, particularly in the mornings. Moving up to 50 gallons gives you a cushion without jumping all the way to gas or a significantly larger unit.
This unit also makes sense for all-electric homes in Utah County and Salt Lake County where gas service at the water heater location isn't already present. Adding a gas line and exhaust venting to an existing home adds cost and sometimes isn't feasible depending on the layout. If you're replacing a failed electric unit and your home doesn't already have gas in that location, staying electric is usually the straightforward path.
For 3 to 4 person households, the 50-gallon electric works well under normal usage patterns. Five or more people under one roof, especially with multiple morning showers happening in quick succession, may still find the 50-gallon electric limiting. In that scenario, the 50-gallon natural gas unit's faster recovery time would serve you better.
Understanding Electric's Limitations and Strengths
The main limitation of electric water heaters is recovery time. Heating 50 gallons of water from 50 degrees to 120 degrees takes around two hours with a dual-element electric unit. During that recovery window, if the tank gets drawn below a certain level, you'll notice the water getting progressively less hot. Gas units recover in roughly half that time.
Electric units have real advantages that tend to get overlooked. There's no combustion exhaust to manage, which simplifies the install and removes one whole category of maintenance. No pilot light, no thermocouple, no gas valve. When something eventually goes wrong with an electric unit, diagnosing it is usually fast and the fix is usually cheap.
Electric water heaters also don't require a dedicated exhaust flue, which is relevant in condos, townhomes, and homes where running a new vent to the exterior would require significant construction. If your current water heater is electric and it's been working fine for your household, replacing it with the same type is often the smartest choice.
The A.O. Smith ProLine 50-Gallon Electric
A.O. Smith builds the ProLine 50-gallon electric with dual heating elements: an upper element that handles the initial heat-up and a lower element for maintaining temperature. The standard configuration uses 4,500-watt elements. The tank has a glass lining and a magnesium anode rod that helps slow corrosion in Utah's mineral-heavy water supply.
The unit requires a dedicated 240-volt, 30-amp circuit. Our installers verify the existing circuit meets requirements before starting the installation. If the panel needs an upgrade or a new circuit added, we'll let you know upfront.
Our all-in price of $1,830 covers the A.O. Smith unit, professional installation by a licensed Utah plumber, expansion tank, drain pan, upgraded connections, earthquake straps, and full haul-away of your old unit. Everything is included.
