Where the 19-Gallon Compact Fits
The 19-gallon compact is a specialized unit, and it's very good at what it's designed for. This is not a unit for a family home or even a typical two-person household. It's built for situations where space is extremely limited and hot water demand is modest.
The most common installs we do with this unit are in studio apartments, accessory dwelling units (ADUs), basement kitchenettes, detached workshops with a bathroom, and homes where a secondary bathroom far from the main water heater needs supplemental hot water. In those settings, the 19-gallon compact does exactly what it's supposed to do.
For a single person with modest hot water needs, it's workable as a primary unit. You'll get roughly two short showers before you're drawing cool water and waiting for recovery. For two people sharing a space, especially if shower timing overlaps, you'll feel the limitation. That's not a knock on the product; it's simply the honest performance envelope for a 19-gallon tank.
Why Under-Counter Electric Makes Sense Here
The reason this unit is electric rather than gas is straightforward: at this size and in these installation locations, running a gas line and a flue vent rarely makes sense. Under-counter spaces, small utility closets, and ADU mechanical rooms are typically not set up for gas appliances. Electric keeps the installation clean and simple.
The compact footprint is a genuine advantage. The unit sits under a standard kitchen counter with room to spare, and unlike a standard 40 or 50-gallon tank, it doesn't need dedicated floor space or a large utility closet. For ADUs and smaller builds where square footage is at a premium, that matters.
From an operating cost perspective, a 19-gallon unit uses relatively little electricity simply because there's much less water to heat. Even though electric is more expensive per BTU than gas, the smaller volume makes the monthly operating cost quite low.
The A.O. Smith 19-Gallon Compact
A.O. Smith designed this unit specifically for under-counter and tight-space applications. It has a low-profile design that allows it to fit in cabinet spaces a standard water heater couldn't come close to fitting in. The unit runs on a standard 120-volt connection in some configurations, though the version we install typically uses a 240-volt connection for better recovery performance.
Despite the compact size, it includes the same glass-lining and anode rod protection that A.O. Smith puts in its full-size ProLine units. It's not a stripped-down product; it's a purpose-built one.
Our all-in price of $1,730 covers the unit, professional installation by a licensed Utah plumber, expansion tank, drain pan, upgraded connections, earthquake straps as required by code, and haul-away of your old unit. All-inclusive, no hidden charges.
